Best in Show: The Journey of “Best in Show” at The New York Times

In 2000, the film Best in Show took the world by storm with its quirky and hilarious take on the world of competitive dog shows. Directed by Christopher Guest, the movie has remained a fan favorite and continues to be referenced as one of the finest examples of the mockumentary genre. This article explores the journey of Best in Show, from its conception to its impact on audiences and critics alike, particularly through the lens of its coverage in The New York Times.

What is “Best in Show”?

Best in Show is a satirical mockumentary that offers a glimpse into the lives of five eccentric dog owners as they compete in a prestigious national dog show. With an offbeat sense of humor and an absurdly relatable cast of characters, it taps into the competitive spirit we all know too well, whether it’s in sports, school, or even something as niche as dog shows.

Background of the Film “Best in Show”

The brain behind Best in Show is none other than Christopher Guest, known for his unique style of filmmaking, especially within the mockumentary subgenre. Guest had previously achieved success with This is Spinal Tap, and with Best in Show, he brought his signature improvisational style to the world of dog competitions. The film was released in 2000 and was met with critical acclaim for its clever writing, outstanding performances, and razor-sharp wit.

Plot Overview of “Best in Show”

At its core, Best in Show follows the journey of five dog owners and their precious pooches as they prepare for and compete in the Mayflower Kennel Club Dog Show. Each character brings their own set of eccentricities, from the uptight yuppies with their neurotic Weimaraner to the flamboyant, effervescent couple who pamper their Shih Tzu beyond belief. The story is more about the people than the dogs, with each couple revealing deeper insecurities, ambitions, and quirks as they navigate the competitive pressures of the show.

Satirical Style and Comedy in “Best in Show”

The humor in Best in Show stems from its mockumentary format. This style allows the film to poke fun at the seriousness with which people treat otherwise trivial events. Much like in Guest’s other films, the brilliance of the comedy is in its deadpan delivery—while the characters are exaggerated, they feel so real that it’s easy to imagine running into them at an actual dog show.

By shining a light on the absurdity of human behavior when caught in competition, Best in Show crafts humor that’s both relatable and unique, making fun of the human condition while also eliciting empathy for these bizarre, passionate individuals.

Notable Characters in “Best in Show”

One of the film’s strengths is its ensemble cast of deeply flawed yet lovable characters. The neurotic attorney Hamilton Swan (Michael Hitchcock) and his equally high-strung wife, Meg Swan (Parker Posey), are unforgettable with their hyper-organized lives and obsessive concern for their Weimaraner, Beatrice. On the other end of the spectrum is Harlan Pepper (Christopher Guest himself), a lovable country man whose deep connection with his bloodhound makes for some of the film’s most touching moments.

The eccentric couple Scott Donlan (John Michael Higgins) and Stefan Vanderhoof (Michael McKean) are also fan favorites. Their over-the-top affection for their Shih Tzu, Miss Agnes, provides comedic gold throughout the film.

Dog Shows in Real Life vs. “Best in Show”

Though Best in Show is a parody, it stays remarkably true to the structure of actual dog shows. Real-life dog show enthusiasts have noted the accuracy with which the movie portrays everything from the rigorous grooming to the intense focus on dog behavior. Of course, the film ramps up the drama for comedic effect, but it’s a surprisingly well-researched spoof.

Cultural Significance of “Best in Show”

Beyond its humor, Best in Show holds a mirror to the world of competition, perfectionism, and obsession in all its forms. It highlights how humans, when placed in any competitive environment, often act in bizarre ways, letting their insecurities and eccentricities shine through. Whether you’re a dog lover or not, the characters’ desperate need for validation speaks to something we’ve all experienced.

The New York Times’ Take on “Best in Show”

When Best in Show premiered, it received glowing reviews from The New York Times. The paper praised it for its clever mockumentary style and ability to find humor in the mundane. One of the most notable comments was on the film’s balance of absurdity and relatability—how it took an obscure subject like dog shows and made it an allegory for human foibles. NYT critics appreciated how the film made its audience care about these ridiculous characters, all while keeping the laughs rolling.

Awards and Recognition for “Best in Show”

Though Best in Show didn’t receive major awards like the Oscars, it garnered several nominations in various film festivals and critics’ awards. It’s a movie that resonated more with niche audiences and cinephiles, securing a spot as a cult classic rather than a mainstream blockbuster.

Christopher Guest’s Signature Style in “Best in Show”

Christopher Guest is a master of the mockumentary, and Best in Show is a testament to his skill. His unique ability to let actors improvise within a loose script gives the film a raw, authentic feel. The characters in Best in Show feel real because much of what they say is ad-libbed, allowing for more organic and spontaneous humor.

Memorable Scenes from “Best in Show”

Several moments from Best in Show have achieved iconic status. One such scene is when Hamilton and Meg Swan have a full-blown meltdown in a pet store because they can’t find the “busy bee” toy their Weimaraner loves. The scene perfectly encapsulates the film’s humor—treating a trivial inconvenience with life-or-death seriousness.

The Cast of “Best in Show”

The cast of Best in Show includes some of the best comedic actors of the era. In addition to Christopher Guest, Parker Posey, and Michael McKean, the ensemble features Eugene Levy, Catherine O’Hara, and Jane Lynch, all of whom deliver performances that elevate the film’s humor.

“Best in Show” and Its Lasting Legacy

Since its release, Best in Show has inspired a generation of filmmakers who admire the mockumentary style. Shows like The Office and Parks and Recreation owe part of their success to the groundwork laid by Guest and his team. The film has become a benchmark in comedic filmmaking, especially in the improvisational and mockumentary genres.

Rewatchability and Nostalgia of “Best in Show”

One of the reasons Best in Show has aged so well is its timeless humor. The characters’ quirks, the absurdity of competitive dog shows, and the underlying human truths are as funny now as they were two decades ago. For many fans, watching Best in Show is like revisiting an old friend, with new layers of humor emerging upon each viewing.

Conclusion

Best in Show remains a beloved classic that continues to charm audiences with its quirky characters, sharp satire, and heartfelt moments. While it may not have been a box office smash, its enduring popularity proves that sometimes, the best comedies are the ones that feel just a little too real.